Insanity Rising: Author Advocates Violent Revolution on MSNBC

By Sean Kerrigan
Wednesday, November 10, 2010


When I started this site, I commented on the increasing likelihood of a fracture in the republic and what President Obama should be doing to soften the discourse. Most commentators call the intensifying hostility “the partisan divide” and while that is accurate, it doesn’t cover the whole picture. Americans’ ideological dissatisfaction with their government and with each other is beginning to manifest itself in unusual and disturbing ways which extend beyond traditional partisan anger.

This trend is still mostly hidden from the average citizen who continues to watch Dancing with the Stars with little knowledge of what’s really going on. But right now, emerging on the fringe of what we call mainstream news, pundits are discussing the validity of violent revolution.

Don’t believe me? Think I’m exaggerating or overstating the point? Watch this.

I know, I know, the MSNBC player sucks.  Sorry

Author and cartoonist Ted Rall argues here and in his book that the revolution is coming and it’s a good thing. He admits that violence is “the last case scenario. The worst case. Nobody wants it.”

But then he goes on to say that the peaceful options have been exhausted, thereby implying that the time for increasingly hostile measures has come. Rall said, “But we’ve seen for the last two years since the economy melted down that neither the Republicans nor the Democrats nor any possible third party is poised to step in.” He continues—“The American left has been very peaceful since the early 70s, since the Kent State shootings, and where has it gotten us?”

Reading brief passages of Rall’s book, it becomes apparent that his complexity of thought is highly questionable. He goes even further to warn his comrades on the left that the right wing zealots will have “minorities and liberals taken away and massacred.”

“A war is coming. At stake: our lives, the planet, freedom, living. The government, the corporations, and the extreme right are prepared to coalesce into an Axis of Evil. Are you going to fight back? Will you do whatever it takes, including taking up arms?”


Good God almighty! That MSNBC put this guy on the air is nothing short of astonishing and to not even challenge Rall on his obvious advocacy for violence is so appalling, I can hardly believe it.

MSNBC host Rachel Maddow rightly criticized Tea Party Senatorial candidate Sharron Angle for making a similar statement about using “second amendment amenities” but this is tolerated by interviewer Dylan Ratigan, even promoted?  Under what reasoning?

Now, if your personal political bias is telling you that there might be some validity to one of these arguments, then I think you're missing the point. I agree that there are substantive problems with the government many of which can only be changed through more fundamental changes, but to suggest that we are at a point where violence is justified is outrageous.


Our leaders should outright condemn this kind of talk.  If you think the time for violent uprising has come, you're probably in opposition to democracy in general or you're quite spoiled and don't know what real political oppression is.

Further Reading:
Hot Air on Rall and His Book
Rachel Maddow on Sharron Angle

Exclusive Features

What President Obama Can Learn From JFK
Facts Are Stubborn Things
Ted Sorensen, The Nation's Peacekeeper
In Defense of Dick Morris
The Real Reason Olbermann Got Canned
Can Triangulation Save Obama?
How to Interpret the Bush Legacy
Insanity Rising: Author Advocates Violent Revolution on MSNBC
Body Screenings: What's Wrong With America?

Other Stories

A "Political Picture of the Year' Contender?
Midterm Ratings: Fox Wins, Broadcast in Close Second
Bush Interview Circuit

Print Archives

Sociologist Blast Left Bias in Field
Call for Unity in African Nation
Resistance Continues on Rt. 202 Construction Plan





Contact                                             Log in

Copyright © 2010 SeanKerrigan.com.  All rights reserved.